GTA 6 isn’t an RPG, but it sure has some excellent role-playing chops
As you might expect, here on RPG Site we spend a disproportionately large amount of time thinking about what is and isn't an RPG. When we have these discussions, we're thinking not just about arbitrary genre definitions, but also about what we deem worthy of coverage. Sometimes that means we make slightly strange, not technically correct decisions.
Take visual novels, for instance. These are definitively not role-playing games, but what we’ve learned over the years is that fans of the RPG genre - our readers - generally love ‘em, and will read coverage about them. They speak to the story-loving streak in many RPG fans. There’s a similar case for The Legend of Zelda, even before it took a more explicitly RPG-esque turn with Breath of the Wild - you were all clear you wanted us to cover it, and so we did.
We’ve stretched the definition over the years, from writing about strategy fare like XCOM to declaring Street Fighter 6’s single-player a fighter-RPG. The mission here is to give the RPG genre faithful a heads up when something not in their wheelhouse might tickle their fancy - and today, another such title joins that list.
Enter Grand Theft Auto VI, Rockstar Games’ latest open-world action adventure. It’s so good that it’s practically criminal - in every sense of the word - but as I dumped some 120 hours into what is arguably the most hotly-anticipated game of all time while reviewing it for RPG Site’s sister site Respec, one intrusive thought kept surfacing: GTA6 is no RPG, but it does have some seriously captivating role-playing chops.
Much of this is the direct result of the game's increased dedication to and focus on having the world react to the way you exist in it. These reactions don't just take the form of moment-to-moment gameplay, but in fact reverberate right through the game, which takes a long-term, holistic view of the way you conduct yourself, the world driven to respond accordingly. This leads to some stuff that is emergent, some that is scripted, and a lot that should be like catnip to role-playing fans.
This is primarily driven by an all-new system for GTA6 known as the ‘Criminal Profile’. In the RPG world, the easiest comparison is perhaps to the morality system in a series like Mass Effect. Here, instead of Paragon or Renegade, Dark or Light, you have a sliding scale of criminality, ranging from those who commit their crimes with a great degree of restraint and while avoiding unnecessary violence (Professional) through to those who show no regard for the lives or livelihoods of those around them (Psycho). There are a few ranks in between, and there's also actually one basement-bottom criminal profile known as Irredeemable, which cannot be reversed and significantly changes the flow of the game's story.
For all but the most relentlessly violent, GTA6 will spend its time oscillating the player characters up and down this sliding scale of criminal profiles, with actions you take granting you points that feed into one or another of the profiles - whichever you’re most aligned to becomes your official profile.
Under the watchful eye of this system, a player simply can’t help but begin to roleplay at least a little. If you're driving around in a sloppy manner and run down a pedestrian, that is definitely not a Professional action; it's violent, perhaps even psychotic. If you rob a store and act with total restraint, keeping the situation contained, and then escape before the cops even arrive, that’s a professional act. If you're somewhere in the middle and botch your bank job and end up in a lengthy police chase that involves a lot of shooting, then that is likely to fall somewhere in the middle. Naturally, the gameplay systems with which you commit crimes has been broadened to allow a much wider range of possibilities - there’s now multiple ways to do more or less everything, right down to the act of stealing a car.
The profile isn’t just about criminality, though - helping out a random NPC with a problem might grant you a chirp towards a more positive profile; getting into a bar fight for no reason might push you towards a more violent one. This system runs through the game as its very backbone, which is quite brave considering it’s a new addition to a very established series.
This system meshes with the four different tiers of relationship between the game's two protagonists, Jason and Lucia. They’re a couple, but you have the choice of how - or if - you nurture the relationship. If the pair are truly in love, the narrative will play out differently than if they’re simply held together by circumstance. These systems collide and intersect with other emergent behaviors to profoundly impact how the game unfolds. There are variations in cutscenes, in dialogue, and in the reactions NPCs have to you in the world. Best of all, most of these reactions aren’t obviously telegraphed in a ‘XYZ will remember that’ way - stuff just goes differently, and you’ll need to play again or talk to another player to discover exactly how.
These morality mechanics are a surprising addition to a game franchise that has often been at its most appreciated when it’s been about totally nihilistic destruction. But it also makes sense for where we’re at. With the advent of Grand Theft Auto Online, players retrofitted the world for role-playing, launching hugely successful servers built around persistent player presence and progression alongside low-key serious RP and simulation. Rockstar ultimately hired some of the folks behind some of this, and one can sense the studio took notes on the successes of these fan endeavors, too.
So while the concept of feeding characters and hitting the gym is not new for GTA - it had that back on the PS2 - here these systems slot together with those combined above, plus new systems that govern things like car ownership, and create a world that isn’t just an action-adventure, but pushes more towards an open world simulation. It feels more than ever like you are truly embodying these dual protagonists. You’re invited to think as they do, and through your decisions both in story missions and open world shenanigans you thereby shape a new and unique version of them.
It isn't a role-playing game, as there isn’t really that mechanical scope - but it feels like a role-playing game. I was getting that same thrill from making story decisions in this game, and even just making minor open-world approach decisions, that I would get out of following and making story choices in something like Mass Effect. When I lost control of situations and had to act in a way my character wouldn’t in order to survive, I found myself getting delightfully frustrated. That is RPG stuff to me. What followed, I suppose, was something that for me is often relatively unique to role-playing games: I truly became attached to these characters on a deeper level than I usually would in a game like this.
Choice and consequence is always smoke and mirrors in video games, of course. Us RPG hardcore are veterans of Mass Effect 3; we know that. With that said, when considering GTA6 I can say that I have seldom seen more voluminous smoke or more perfectly polished mirrors. It’ll probably somewhat collapse under scrutiny, but in a single play-through, Jason and Lucia’s story felt totally uniquely mine.
As you can read in depth in my review over on Respec, even more mechanics than mentioned here feed into this system encouraging you to play this game in an RPG-like fashion. That doesn’t kneecap the shenanigans (perhaps your Jason is a nihilistic psycho!), but it gives players choice and options. Here is a GTA game where I genuinely worked to play it in a non-lethal way, involving innocents - including cops - as little as possible.
Other mechanics then flow from giving the player such an option. I became meticulous in my criminal lifestyle. I carried face coverings, hats, and changes of clothes in the trunk of my car to help anonymize myself after a heist. In the GTA games of old, you would commit a crime and simply run until the police stopped coming. Here, these role-playing style systems are deeply integrated into the mechanical flow of the game - slipping the police feels mechanical, grounded, and real at last - and it feels tremendous.
If you are an RPG fan who has typically had little to no interest in the stories and mechanics of Grand Theft Auto, GTA6 may pleasantly surprise you or even totally surpass your expectations. It's a different sort of game to anything that has come before in this series, more thoughtful, more considered, and far more effective with its storytelling. It is not a role-playing game, and you won't be seeing any more coverage of it on RPG Site beyond this one-off piece. But what it is, for sure, is something that RPG fans may want to consider giving a look.
For more on Grand Theft Auto 6, check out our extensive coverage over on Respec.