In a world of RPG remakes, now is the time for Falcom to revisit Brandish 2: The Planet Buster
Stop me if you've felt the same - video game remakes can be a contentious topic online, yet it's clear that developers revisiting their past efforts to bring them back to the forefront isn't going anywhere. I've been thinking about how remakes tie into game development timelines a lot with the recent releases of Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026). One of those thoughts is pretty simple; If Nihon Falcom is looking to revive some of its older IPs, with projects like the upcoming Dragon Slayer, there couldn't be a better time to remake and revive a classic - Brandish 2: The Planet Buster.
While I never covered it for RPG Site, I was a massive fan of Brandish: The Dark Revenant when XSEED brought the title over back in 2015, and that appreciation has only grown in the years since. So many of Falcom's modern releases are bloated, filled with so much content that it suffocates the experience of enjoying a brisk RPG. It was one of my primary problems with Kyoto Xanadu when I played it earlier this year, and yet Falcom has proven that they can show restraint when revisiting their older titles.
The Trails in the Sky remakes are a perfect example; while they're still long RPGs, they pale in comparison to the company's recent Trails releases, and are arguably all the better for it. Falcom's back catalogue is full of games like this, and it used to be to their benefit that you could knock out an Ys over a weekend or two. Brandish: The Dark Revenant was an RPG along those lines, and having recently played Brandish 2: Renewal - the sequel doesn't suffer from bloat, either.
It's clear that Falcom hopes to get into the habit of releasing multiple games a year, but it's hard to see how they could accomplish this if they keep shooting for larger and larger scopes for their titles. A top-down remake of Brandish 2, in the same vein as Brandish: The Dark Revenant would doubtlessly take far less effort than yet another 3D Action RPG with full camera controls, all the while reviving a dormant - yet beloved - Falcom franchise.
I would love a new Brandish as well, but remaking Brandish 2 feels like it makes more sense for now. Give the modern Falcom developers more of a feel for how these games were designed, much like Nintendo has done with this month's Ocarina of Time remake; there's already a very devoted fanbase for Brandish 2 in the west, and surely I don't need to say how much of a benefit that could be in marketing a series revival?
In Falcom's case, where the studio has struggled to release even one game a year, remakes have been a boon that helps balance the load. By their own admission, The Legend of Heroes: Trails through Daybreak 2 would not have existed if not for the necessity to have a game ready to go when Ys X: Nordics required another year of development. Remakes can give Falcom the extra time to make sure their new titles have all the polish they need, which I can certainly hope bears fruit with next year's follow-up to Trails Beyond the Horizon.
Game budgets and development timelines keep increasing, and at a certain point there has to be an acceptance that remakes of games are a necessity in the modern market. Grand Theft Auto VI launches this week after 13 years since Grand Theft Auto V; a gap which fit Grand Theft Auto 3, Vice City, San Andreas, and all the handheld spin-offs. The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom took 7 years to release after Breath of the Wild, despite re-using much of the game world; Ocarina of Time's remake took 3 years, all the while a main team was presumably sharing their focus with the next mainline entry.
Maybe I'm just shouting into the void; perhaps Falcom has no desire to return to Brandish. Yet if there's even a remote chance they're listening; remake Brandish 2. It feels as much of a surefire win as anything else, and frankly I would want nothing more than a new Falcom release that doesn't eclipse 30 hours. I love Ys and Trails, but it was the variety of experiences that Falcom used to offer that made me a fan in the first place - I hope there's still a desire for those sorts of projects in the company, somewhere.