"The end of physical media was declared many years ago, but we continued to see strong demand for them" – Marvelous USA CEO Ken Berry on physical games, Switch 2 cartridges, Muramasa, PS5 ports, Game Key Cards, Xbox releases, and much more

"The end of physical media was declared many years ago, but we continued to see strong demand for them" – Marvelous USA CEO Ken Berry on physical games, Switch 2 cartridges, Muramasa, PS5 ports, Game Key Cards, Xbox releases, and much more

Last year, I interviewed Marvelous USA/XSEED Games' President and CEO Ken Berry just before the Nintendo Switch 2 launched to discuss physical games, how the company was prepping for the Switch 2 with titles arriving right from launch day with Rune Factory: Guardians of Azuma, multi-platform releases with Daemon X Machina: Titanic Scion, 3DS games, and much more. Over a year later, I've had another conversation with Ken about how the last year of physical releases have gone, Sony's announcement for ending physical disc production for new releases from 2028, doing physical releases for games getting Game-Key Card releases in other regions, the state of the physical games market right now, and much more.

RPG Site: It has been over a year since we last had a chance to chat. How have you been?

Ken Berry: 
I’m doing well, thank you. How about yourself?

RPG Site: I'm great, thanks. How has the last year been for Marvelous USA and XSEED Games?

Ken Berry:
Extremely busy, as we had 3 titles (Rune Factory: Guardians of Azuma, Story of Seasons: Grand Bazaar, and Daemon X Machina: Titanic Scion) launch within the 3-month launch window of the Nintendo Switch 2 hardware last year. Things have been a bit slower this year, with our main new release being the indie title Moonlight Peaks back in July.
RPG Site: A lot has changed or will change in the world of physical games across platforms with Sony deciding to stop discs for new games in 2028, Nintendo releasing a 32GB card format allowing for more physical releases, Xbox implementing a disc to digital license program, and more. As one of the best publishers for retail releases right now in my opinion, I want to pick your brain on a few things including your thoughts on the industry right now. First, can you discuss how it was launching Rune Factory: Guardians of Azuma? It was Marvelous USA's first time being a part of a hardware or new console launch. 

Ken Berry: 
It was definitely a huge honor to have a title as part of the initial launch lineup with the Nintendo Switch 2 hardware last year. There was a lot of uncertainty about what format to use for the physical release since I can’t recall there ever being more than a single option on any previous platform when it came to manufacturing, but in the end I think we made the right call going with the full ROM game cards as I believe the game was the 2nd best selling third-party title at launch, only behind another full ROM game card release in Cyberpunk 2077.
RPG Site: Story of Seasons: Grand Bazaar followed months later on the same platforms, but we then had Daemon X Machina: Titanic Scion launch for all current platforms. How have the Switch 2 physical versions been doing specifically? I'm not asking for numbers, I'm just curious if you and everyone else on the team is happy with the physical Switch 2 sales.

Ken Berry: 
The latest Story of Seasons and Rune Factory offerings in particular have been strong on Switch 2, with both titles slightly outselling their original Switch counterparts. The original Switch still does very well for physical releases, so we were happy that the new platform was continuing Nintendo’s tradition of a strong retail presence for their platforms.

Daemon X Machina: Titanic Scion, being the only title that launched on all platforms simultaneously, was really interesting because the Switch 2 retail edition outsold the PS5 physical almost 2-to-1, while on digital the PS5 outsold Switch 2 by 2-to-1.
RPG Site: What about the PS5 and Xbox retail releases when available?

Ken Berry: 
We still try to release on PS5 physically, though admittedly that platform has a stronger digital ratio for software sales than Nintendo platforms, as per the Daemon X Machina example. Xbox we had also been releasing physically as much as we can, but due to Xbox Game Pass that platform’s user base is most comfortable with digital releases so we will likely not be doing many physical releases going forward.
RPG Site: How was it working with Amazon for North American PS5 disc releases for both titles? 

Ken Berry: Having the PS5 versions come out more than 6 months after the original release we knew our retail options would be limited, so by making them exclusive to Amazon we could be assured that the main place that was going to stock the games anyways was even more motivated to push for their success. We were happy with the partnership and the results.
RPG Site: One more title XSEED Games / Marvelous launched physically and digitally is the new Ys Celceta Switch port. Celceta's Vita Limited Edition you did years ago was what got me to check out Falcom games in the first place. I consider it a very important game personally. With the Switch 2 now in full swing, do you see yourself doing more Switch 1 physical and digital releases thanks to backward compatibility?

Ken Berry: 
I’m not sure if that specifically will have much of an impact as we had already been releasing most everything we can physically on the original Switch. But while we’re talking about physical editions, I feel the ability of “Nintendo Switch 2 Edition” games to provide players with both the full Switch 2 version and the scaled down regular Switch version on a single game card is not talked about enough. 

On these releases even people who only own the regular Switch can purchase and play a Switch 2 game card, and then not have to worry about having to upgrade their game if they ever get a Switch 2. I guess this could be called forward compatibility, but either way it is something that is quite unique and could have come in handy when the PS5 first launched.
RPG Site: In the past year, you already did more proper Switch 2 physicals than almost all third party publishers on Switch 2. This year you are continuing the tradition while Marvelous EU and the JP side are doing Game-Key Cards. I have a few questions about this. The first is have things become easier for publishers to bring out proper game on cart physical releases this year compared to last year?

Ken Berry: 
No, I would actually say that it’s getting harder because as Game-Key Cards are getting more and more accepted, the pressure to go for the cheaper option grows. Future uncertainty on pricing on anything that contains computer chips due to what’s affectionately called the ongoing RAMpocalypse would point to disc-based or Game-Key Card releases as maybe having even a greater cost advantage in the future.
RPG Site: Muramasa is a huge deal not just for the Switch 2 physical release, but also because it is Vanillaware's first Steam release as far as I am aware. It is great to see you push both aspects of the upcoming release. Can you say whether the push to have it on PC came from your side, Marvelous in Japan, or did Vanillaware want to do it for this release?

Ken Berry: 
This decision was reached through mutual consultation between Marvelous and Vanillaware.
RPG Site: Is the PC port being done internally or by an external company?

Ken Berry: 
The PC port is being done internally by Vanillaware.
RPG Site: Muramasa Rebirth on Vita is another game I imported the big LE release for, from Aksys at the time, and I'm glad to see it get a lovely physical bundle this time as well. You've usually done more than the Japanese side when it comes to these sorts of releases like with Hundred Line. Has there ever been a case where the JP license holder was against you doing more for the North American release?

Ken Berry: 
Yes, that does come up from time-to-time, especially as the easiest route would be to standardize the physical release across all territories whether it be the use of a full ROM game card versus Game-Key Card, having a printed insert within the case, or even if the inner coverslip should have anything printed on it or not such as reversible box art or just bonus artwork. We are usually lucky in that most teams know we always try to do what we feel is best for our North American market, but we understand when there are times that we are limited to what other territories are doing.
RPG Site: From my point of view, even on Switch 1, the NA versions have been the way to go for the booklet and reversible covers included in every release compared to how the EU side handles things physically.

Ken Berry: 
Every region is unique, and I know the EU in particular can be very challenging for physical releases due to all the different countries and languages they have to accommodate, which makes including a single booklet with only English text like we do not possible for them. Even then, as we touched on earlier, there have been times when we have been unable to implement some of the bonuses that we wanted to for whatever reason, but we will never stop trying.
RPG Site: I saw some pushback for the higher price on Switch 2 for Muramasa despite most people understanding why. When we last spoke, you mentioned how the financial side of things needs to work to do these physical releases and it leads to Switch 2 versions costing more. Has there been any change on that front given the memory crisis for physical games and potential shipping delays?

Ken Berry: 
No change yet, and if anything we’ve announced two more titles since then where the physical Nintendo Switch 2 offering has a $10 premium over other retail versions; Fate/EXTRA Record and Eternal Anima. For all 3 titles the most expensive Switch 2 version is the best pre-ordering one, so I think fans are aware of the situation and supportive of what we are doing.
RPG Site: For the titles you are launching on Switch 1 and 2 like Fate Extra/Record or Muramasa, will there be an upgrade path like Story of Seasons and Rune Factory last year?

Ken Berry: 
No, these titles are set up as completely separate products on Switch and Switch 2, so there will be no upgrade path.
RPG Site: Given the production time, how are you managing doing physical releases for worldwide simultaneous launches on multiple platforms now? 

Ken Berry: 
This is something we’ve been working very hard together with our parent company Marvelous on to get simultaneous worldwide launches on all our recent titles. It takes a lot of hustling on the localization side, whether it be our US office working to translate the original Japanese into English or our European sister company helping oversee the localization into the other European languages, as well as some patience on Japan’s side to wait for us in the West to have enough time after receiving their materials to prep everything for release so we can all go out together.
RPG Site: While it might just be a small sample size, I definitely have seen a lot of people who live in Asia and Europe mention placing import orders for the NA versions of Switch 2 games to get the game on cart. Is this something you keep track of or is it just for the retailers to worry about?

Ken Berry: 
Our online store only ships domestically to consumers within the US, we are unable to even ship to Canada, so this is never an issue for us directly. Though we do see the occasional comment online, I imagine anybody actually doing this and paying the large overseas shipping charges are very few in number as we know most of the retailers and distributors we work with have the bulk of their customers within the US and Canada.
RPG Site: What are your thoughts on the state of physical games in North America right now?

Ken Berry: 
The end of physical media was declared many years ago, but we continued to see strong demand for them, especially the premium SKUs such as limited editions. But I would say in the past year or two it has really shifted where after the initial shipment of units goes out at launch, even if it sells through to the end consumers really well we don’t get the kind of reorders from retailers to restock their inventory the way we used to.

These days retailers want to just order enough units to fulfill pre-orders and then move onto other upcoming new releases where sales are essentially guaranteed thanks to pre-orders rather than restocking older releases, so we definitely need to be more careful about the number of units we manufacture than before.
RPG Site: Sony's announcement for 2028 has been a huge blow for a lot of boutique publishers worldwide who, at least from my point of view, benefit a lot from physical and limited edition releases. As someone who still buys a lot of physical games, I've obviously been thinking of moving to buying more on other consoles physically. How is Marvelous USA / XSEED Games going to deal with PlayStation releases going forward if you can say? 

Ken Berry: 
With our release slate in the past couple years being so Nintendo-heavy it won’t hurt us as much as it would have a few years ago, plus compared to Nintendo platforms, PlayStation has been very vocal about how their platform has a much higher digital mix, so I am cautiously optimistic that it won’t affect us too negatively.
RPG Site: Are you still seeing a lot of demand for physical releases of your current and past titles? 

Ken Berry: 
Moreso on upcoming titles as pre-orders for special editions continue to be very strong because people want the additional bonus goods, but that is offset by less demand for the base version as the convenience of purchasing digitally is hard to beat when the main interest is just in playing the game itself. Demand for past titles has dropped considerably, which is surely why retailers have shifted to concentrate more on pushing pre-orders for upcoming new releases.
RPG Site: Do you reprint a lot of Switch 1/2 or PlayStation physicals of older games?

Ken Berry: 
Not very much as the main outlets for older titles would be Amazon and some distributors. We often get approached by distributors to reprint older titles, but the pricing they offer rarely makes it worth the effort.
RPG Site: While I know this interview is focused on physical games and the state of the industry, this isn't a question, but I hope you consider releasing some of the Senran Kagura games and Uppers on Nintendo Switch 2 while doing NMH 1/2 on PS5/Xbox and even Travis Strikes Again on Xbox. These feel like gaps in the library that I would love to see plugged. 

Ken Berry: 
With all those titles still available on PC and most of them on at least one modern console, the amount of incremental sales from doing a straight port to yet another platform or two almost surely wouldn’t recoup the investment needed, so afraid the chances are extremely slim.
RPG Site: Moonlight Peaks was an interesting launch since you also brought it out on Google Play, but not iOS on the mobile side. Do you have more titles like that planned and will Moonlight Peaks come to iOS?

Ken Berry: 
That was done in close partnership with Google from even before the title launched as it caught their eye and they wanted it released on their platform. Google was a great partner and offered a lot of marketing support at launch to help it achieve higher sales than expected for a premium title on mobile, so together with the development team at Little Chicken we may need to explore the possibility of bringing the title to iOS at some point in the future too.
RPG Site: Are there any plans to do more with Hundred Line when it comes to retail re-releases or merchandise from your side? A PC physical release would also be good to have in North America.

Ken Berry: 
As long as the price is right we are always willing to build more of a product again as long as our license is still valid with the IP holder, but no plans to create any merchandise for that title. Even less plans to try to do anything with the PC release as Aniplex self-published the title on that platform.
RPG Site: Since I already asked you about coffee last year, I'm curious if you've changed how you drink coffee this year and also if you've watched any movies you enjoyed lately? 

Ken Berry: 
Still take my coffee with milk, no sugar. As for movies, I’ve always been a fan of westerns and sci-fi, and a couple absolute gems in those genres that I’ve seen recently are Old Henry and Good Luck, Have Fun, Don’t Die, respectively. Old Henry had a great buildup to the final climatic scene that fans of Unforgiven will enjoy, while Good Luck, Have Fun, Don’t Die is the closest movie I’ve seen to Everything Everywhere All at Once, so try to go into that movie without knowing anything about it if you like wild rollercoaster rides for a plot.